Much recent study of welfare states has focused on (1) the development
of typologies and (2) theories explaining the development of welfare
states. This article seeks to raise some specific questions about the
current approaches to the study of welfare states. Using the example o
f the Republic of Ireland to highlight deficiencies in existing studie
s, it argues that dominant approaches are core-centric and adopt - eit
her implicity or explicitly - a modernization approach, thereby margin
alizing the experience of peripheral countries and abstracting the dev
elopment of welfare states from the world economic system in which it
takes place. Looking at the case of Ireland, it is suggested that ther
e are a number of factors which have influenced the development of the
Irish welfare state but which are frequently not taken into account i
n comparative studies. These include the country's colonial and post-c
olonial status: the largely agricultural nature of Irish society; the
impact of being a dependent peripheral country (including the active r
ole played by the state in developing policy); and the role of Catholi
cism.