Fe. Marx et al., A COMPARISON OF 2 SETS OF PRIMERS FOR THE RT-PCR DETECTION OF ASTROVIRUSES IN ENVIRONMENTAL-SAMPLES, Water S.A., 23(3), 1997, pp. 257-262
Human astroviruses (HAstV) are associated with sporadic cases and outb
reaks of diarrhoe. The faecal-oral route is the predominant mode of tr
ansmission and contaminated drinking water and shellfish have been imp
licated as vehicles of transmission. Conventional diagnostic technique
s have limited sensitivity and in this study two primer pairs, designa
ted Jon and Mon, were compared for the detection of HAstV in environme
ntal specimens by the reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction
(RT-PCR). Both primer pairs yielded positive RT-PCR products for the c
ell culture adapted HAstV-1 positive control. The Jon primers, however
, also yielded positive results for other viruses as well as for a num
ber of water samples. These data suggest that the regions amplified by
the Jon primers are not unique to HAstV. The Mon primer pair yielded
positive RT-PCR results only for HAstV serotypes 1 to 4 and some envir
onmental samples. The results obtained using the Mon primer pair could
be confirmed by either hybridisation with an oligonucleotide probe sp
ecific for HAstV or a HAstV specific enzyme immunoassay (EIA). RT-PCR,
using the Mon primers, proved more sensitive than electron microscopy
(EM), immune electron microscopy (IEM) and EIA for the direct detecti
on of HAstV in river water. Cell culture amplification using the PLC/P
RF/5 human primary liver carcinoma cell line improved the sensitivity
of HAstV detection by EIA and RT-PCR, but not EM and IEM. The sensitiv
ity of the RT-PCR assay system was enhanced by prior viral recovery by
a glass wool adsorption-elution technique.