Judging survey quality: Local variances

Citation
Ht. Wolterbeek et Tg. Verburg, Judging survey quality: Local variances, ENV MON ASS, 73(1), 2002, pp. 7-16
Citations number
16
Categorie Soggetti
Environment/Ecology
Journal title
ENVIRONMENTAL MONITORING AND ASSESSMENT
ISSN journal
01676369 → ACNP
Volume
73
Issue
1
Year of publication
2002
Pages
7 - 16
Database
ISI
SICI code
0167-6369(2002)73:1<7:JSQLV>2.0.ZU;2-W
Abstract
The present study was undertaken to explore possibilities to judge survey q uality on basis of a limited and restricted number of a-priori observations . Here, quality is defined as the ratio between survey and local variance ( signal-to-noise ratio). The results indicate that the presented surveys do not permit such judgement. Furthermore, the discussion also suggests that t he 5-fold local sampling strategies do not merit any sound judgement in abo ut 10% of all cases. The results further imply that surveys will benefit fr om procedures, controls and approaches in sampling and sample handling, to assess both average, variance and the nature of the distribution of element al concentrations in local sites. This reasoning is compatible with the ide a of the site as a basic homogeneous survey unit, which is implicitly and c onceptually underlying any survey performed.