Objectives Occupational assessments of chemical exposure are often inadequa
te because of difficulties in obtaining sufficient numbers of measurements
by trained professionals (experts). The objective of this study was to dete
rmine whether workers can provide unbiased data via self-assessments of exp
osure facilitated by the use of simple passive monitors for personal sampli
ng.
Methods Untrained workers obtained personal measurements of their exposures
to gaseous contaminants (terpenes in sawmills and styrene in reinforced pl
astics factories) with passive monitors and written instructions. To study
the validity of the self-assessments, an occupational hygienist performed e
xposure measurements on the same occupational groups after the workers had
obtained two or more measurements independently. The potential bias of the
self-assessments was evaluated by comparing the self-assessments with the e
xpert assessments in mixed-effects statistical models.
Results A total of 153 terpene (97 self and 56 expert) and 216 styrene (159
self and 57 expert) measurements were obtained from four sawmills and six
reinforced plastics factories, respectively. No significant differences in
the geometric mean exposures were observed between the self-assessments and
the expert assessments in 3 of 4 sawmills and 5 of 6 reinforced plastics f
actories (P > 0.10). The potential bias of the self-assessments of exposure
ranged from less than 0.1% to 102% and was less than 17% in 9 of the 10 gr
oups investigated.
Conclusions The results indicate that untrained, unsupervised workers are a
ble to collect consistently unbiased exposure data by employing currently a
vailable passive monitors.