Ej. Steinbart et al., Impact of DNA testing for early-onset familial Alzheimer disease and frontotemporal dementia, ARCH NEUROL, 58(11), 2001, pp. 1828-1831
Background: DNA testing of persons at risk for hereditary, degenerative neu
rologic diseases is relatively new. Only anecdotal reports of such testing
in familial Alzheimer disease (FAD) exist, and little is know about the per
sonal and social impact of such testing.
Methods: in a descriptive, observational study, individuals at 50% risk for
autosomal dominant, early-onset FAD or frontotemporal dementia with parkin
sonism linked to chromosome 17 underwent DNA testing for the genetic mutati
ons previously identified in affected family members. Individuals were foll
owed up for (1)/(2) to 3 years and were interviewed regarding attitudes tow
ard the testing process and the impact of the results.
Results: Twenty-one (8.4%) of 251 persons at risk for FAD or frontotemporal
dementia requested genetic testing. The most common reasons for requesting
testing were concern about early symptoms of dementia, financial or family
planning, and relief from anxiety. Twelve individuals had positive DNA tes
t results, and 6 of these had early symptoms of demential 8 had negative re
sults; and I has not vet received results. Of 14 asymptomatic individuals c
ompleting testing, 13 believed the testing was beneficial. Two persons repo
rted moderate anxiety and 1 reported moderate depression. As expected, pers
ons with negative test results had happier experiences overall, but even th
ey had to deal with ongoing anxiety and depression. Thus far, there have be
en no psychiatric hospitalizations, suicide attempts, or denials of insuran
ce.
Conclusions: Genetic testing in early-onset FAD and frontotemporal dementia
can be completed successfully. Most individuals demonstrate effective copi
ng skills and find the testing to be beneficial, but long-term effects rema
in unknown.