In this paper we investigate how best to model naturally arising distributi
ons of colour camera data. It has become standard to model single mode dist
ributions of colour data by ignoring the intensity component and constructi
ng a Gaussian model of the chromaticity. This approach is appealing, becaus
e the intensity of data can change arbitrarily due to shadowing and shading
, whereas the chromaticity is more robust to these effects. However, it is
unclear how best to construct such a model, since there are many domains in
which the chromaticity can be represented. Furthermore, the applicability
of this kind of model is questionable in all but the most basic lighting en
vironments.
We begin with a review of the reflection processes that give rise to distri
butions of colour data. Several candidate models are then presented; some a
re from the existing literature and some are novel. Properties of the diffe
rent models are compared analytically and the models are empirically compar
ed within a region tracking application over two separate sets of data. Res
ults show that chromaticity based models perform well in constrained enviro
nments where the physical model upon which they are based applies. It is fu
rther found that models based on spherical representations of the chromatic
ity data provide better performance than those based on more common planar
representations, such as the chromaticity plane or the normalised colour sp
ace. In less constrained environments, however, such as daylight, chromatic
ity based models do not perform well, because of the effects of additional
illumination components, which violate the physical model upon which they a
re based.