Trichogaster pectoralis Regan is often cultured successfully in rice fields
in South-cast Asia. However, since the advent of high-yielding rice variet
ies and intensive rice cropping, several reports suggest poorer growth perf
ormance of the species. In this paper, we investigated the growth performan
ce of T. pectoralis in rice-fish systems characterized by intensive rice cu
lture and extensive to semi-intensive polyculture of Oreochromis nilotictis
(L.), Cyprinus carpio L. and Barbodes gonionotus (Bleeker). In these syste
ms, T. pectoralis recorded negative net productions. This was mainly the re
sult of a negative specific growth rate (SGR) when fish had to stay in the
trench (-0.519% body weight day(-1)) or when fish had free access to the ri
ce crop (-0.081). Only when harvested rice plants were allowed to generate
new tillers (ratooning) did T. pectoralis perform slightly better (0.453% b
ody weight day(-1)). The SGR of T. pectoralis was low owing to a lack of fo
od in intensive rice systems. The other species, all with SGR values higher
than 1% body weight day(-1), clearly had a competitive advantage over T. p
ectoralis. We concluded that intensification of rice cropping did indeed re
sult in poor T. pectoralis growth. Successful T. pectoralis culture is only
possible in areas of traditional rice cropping.