R. Thomson, The programme to policy linkage: The fulfilment of election pledges on socio-economic policy in the Netherlands, 1986-1998, EUR J POL R, 40(2), 2001, pp. 171-197
To what extent are the contents of party election programmes congruent with
subsequent government policy actions? Existing research on the fulfilment
of pre-election pledges focuses on systems of government in which executive
s formed by a single parties are the norm. This study extends this research
to coalition systems of government. Specific policy proposals made by the
main Dutch parties in their recent election programmes are identified and c
ompared with subsequent government policy actions. Hypotheses about the con
ditions under which pledges are more likely to be acted upon are formulated
and tested. Although clear linkages between election programmes and subseq
uent policies are found, pledges made by prospective coalition parties in t
he Netherlands are less likely to be acted upon than those made by prospect
ive governing parties in the United Kingdom. Prominent features of cabinet
government, such as the allocation of ministerial portfolios and the coalit
ion policy agreement, are found to influence the likelihood of pledges bein
g fulfilled. In addition, consensus between parties is also found to increa
se the likelihood of government actions responding to election pledges.