The Golgi apparatus comprises an enormous array of components that generate
its unique architecture and function within cells. Here, we use quantitati
ve fluorescence imaging techniques and ultrastructural analysis to address
whether the Golgi apparatus is a steady-state or a stable organelle. We fou
nd that all classes of Golgi components are dynamically associated with thi
s organelle, contrary to the prediction of the stable organelle model. Enzy
mes and recycling components are continuously exiting and reentering the Go
lgi apparatus by membrane trafficking pathways to and from the ER, whereas
Golgi matrix proteins and coatomer undergo constant, rapid exchange between
membrane and cytoplasm. When ER to Golgi transport is inhibited without di
srupting COPII-dependent ER export machinery (by brefeldin A treatment or e
xpression of Arf1 [T31N]), the Golgi structure disassembles, leaving no res
idual Golgi membranes. Rather, all Golgi components redistribute into the E
R, the cytoplasm, or to ER exit sites still active for recruitment of selec
tive membrane-bound and peripherally associated cargos. A similar phenomeno
n is induced by the constitutively active Sari [H79G] mutant, which has the
additional effect of causing COPII-associated membranes to cluster to a ju
xtanuclear region. In cells expressing Sar1[T39N], a constitutively inactiv
e form of Sari that completely disrupts ER exit sites, Golgi glycosylation
enzymes, matrix, and itinerant proteins all redistribute to the ER. These r
esults argue against the hypothesis that the Golgi apparatus contains stabl
e components that can serve as a template for its biogenesis. Instead, they
suggest that the Golgi complex is a dynamic, steady-state system, whose me
mbranes can be nucleated and are maintained by the activities of the Sar1-C
OPII and Arf1-coatomer systems.