Checkerboard patterns are quite common in various fixed grid finite element
based structural optimization methods. In the evolutionary structural opti
mization procedure, such checkerboard patterns have been observed under var
ious design criteria. The presence of checkerboard patterns makes the inter
pretation of optimal material distribution and subsequent geometric extract
ion for manufacturing difficult. To prevent checkerboarding, an effective s
moothing algorithm in terms of the surrounding element's reference factors
is proposed in this paper. The approach does not alter the mesh of the fini
te element model, nor increase the degree of freedom of the structural syst
em, therefore, it does not affect the computational efficiency. To demonstr
ate the capabilities of this algorithm, a wide range of illustrative exampl
es are presented in this paper.