The single-crystal elastic moduli of natural samples of both calcite (CaCO3
) and rhodochrosite (MnCO3) have been measured by Brillouin spectroscopy un
der ambient condition. Based on the trigonal unit cell, the elastic constan
ts C-11, C-33, C-44, C-12, C-13, and C-14 are 149.4(7), 85.2(18), 34.1(5),
57.9(11), 53.5(9), -20.0(2), and 223.9(15), 132.6(41), 44.5(9), 93.4(21), 7
6.0(23), -17.3(6) GPa for CaCO3 and MnCO3, respectively. Our data for calci
te are in good agreement with earlier data obtained by ultrasonic experimen
ts. The off-diagonal elastic constants (C-12, C-13, and C-14) for rhodochro
site have systematically larger values than the trend defined by other isos
tructural carbonates, in all of which the divalent cations are alkaline-ear
th metals. This is a distinctive signature of transition-metal-bearing oxid
es, which is present in silicates and simple oxides as well.