A supramolecular complex for investigating the thermodynamic properties of
intermolecular aromatic stacking interactions has been developed. The confo
rmation of the complex is locked in a single well-defined conformation by a
n array of H-bonding interactions that force two aromatic rings on one end
of the complex into a stacked geometry. Chemical double-mutant cycles have
been used to measure an anthracene - aniline interaction (+ 0.6 +/- 0.8 kJ
mol(-1)) and a pentafluorophenyl-aniline interaction (- 0.4 +/- 0.90 kJ mol
(-1)) in this system. Although the interactions are very weak, the pentaflu
orophenyl interaction is attractive, whereas the anthracene interaction is
repulsive this is consistent with the dominance of pi -electron electrostat
ic interactions. The nitropyrrole subunits used to control the conformation
of these complexes lead to problems of aggregation and multiple conformati
onal equilibria. The implications for the thermodynamic analysis are examin
ed in detail, and the double-mutant-cycle approach is found to be remarkabl
y robust with respect to such effects, since systematic errors in individua
l experiments are removed in a pair-wise fashion when the cycle is construc
ted.