Evidence of temporally graded retrograde amnesia (RA) following hippocampal
damage has fuelled the long-standing belief that memory undergoes a consol
idation process, whereby memories are progressively modified in neocortical
regions until they are independent of the hippocampal (HPC) complex. Suppo
rt for this position derives from both the animal and human RA literature,
although the results are not consistent, Specifically, consolidation theory
does not account for loss of episodic (detail) information in humans and c
ontext-dependent information in animals, which often extend back for much o
f the life span. We discuss an alternative approach, the Multiple Trace The
ory, which suggests that the HPC complex contributes to the retrieval of re
cent and remote episodic and context-dependent memories. According to this
view, such memory traces are represented as spatially distributed interacti
ons between the HPC and neocortex that persist for as long as those memorie
s exist. On the other hand, semantic, or context-free, memories can become
independent of the HPC as consolidation theory predicts. In support of this
view, we report recent accounts of relatively flat RA gradients in autobio
graphical and spatial detail loss in patients and animal models with extens
ive bilateral HPC lesions. By comparison, temporally graded RA was observed
in tests of semantic and context-free memory. We also report neuroimaging
studies in which hippocampal activity, elicited during recollection of auto
biographical memories, did not distinguish recent from remote episodes. Our
discussion suggests ways to reconcile discrepancies in the literature and
guide predictions of the occurrence of flat versus temporally limited gradi
ents of remote episodic and semantic memory loss following lesions to HPC.
(C) 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.