Rmh. Roumen et al., Treatment of 100 patients with sentinel node-negative breast cancer without further axillary dissection, BR J SURG, 88(12), 2001, pp. 1639-1643
Background: The sentinel node biopsy technique for breast cancer has been v
alidated extensively in phase I and II studies. However, no data from phase
III randomized clinical studies are available. It remains controversial wh
ether a histologically negative sentinel node biopsy without further axilla
ry dissection can be considered to be good clinical practice.
Methods: One hundred consecutive patients with breast cancer who had a nega
tive sentinel node biopsy without additional axillary dissection were studi
ed prospectively between 1997 and 2000 in order to identify tumour recurren
ce and to assess the morbidity of the sentinel node procedure. Special atte
ntion was paid to axillary or locoregional recurrence, distant metastases a
nd overall survival. One year after the procedure patients were sent a ques
tionnaire to assess any functional impairment of the arm or shoulder.
Results: Median follow-up was 24 (range 16-40) months. One patient had an a
xillary relapse 14 months after the initial diagnosis of breast cancer. She
died after 2 years from metastatic disease. There were no other local axil
lary recurrences. There was a 94 per cent response rate to the questionnair
e. Twelve patients developed mild disabilities, of whom two said that they
had to change their hobbies, sports or daily activities owing to the sentin
el node procedure. No patient developed lymphoedema or needed physiotherapy
after the operation.
Conclusion: When strict criteria for the sentinel node biopsy procedure are
used, the sentinel node biopsy without further axillary dissection after a
negative histological investigation is a safe procedure. It may therefore
be considered to be the standard of care for the treatment of patients with
breast cancer.