S. Adler et al., IgM anticardiolipin antibodies are associated with stenosis of vascular access in hemodialysis patients but do not predict thrombosis, CLIN NEPHR, 56(6), 2001, pp. 428-434
Aim: The prevalence of anticardiolipin antibodies (ACA) is elevated amongst
hemodialysis patients as compared with the general population. Previous st
udies have disagreed as to whether the presence of ACA represents a risk fa
ctor for access thrombosis. Other risk factors for access thrombosis (decre
ased blood flow, elevated venous pressure) have also been described. Materi
als and methods: We performed a combination retrospective and prospective c
ohort study of a single outpatient dialysis unit to assess the association
between these potential risk factors and access thrombosis. ACA, access blo
od flow, presence of stenosis, and venous pressures were measured in 100 pa
tients. Information on episodes of access thrombosis was gathered for 12 mo
nths prior to and 12 months after ACA measurement. Results:, ACA were prese
nt in 19% of patients with equal numbers of IgG- and IgM-ACA. The presence
of IgM-ACA was significantly associated with the use of aspirin and the pre
sence of stenosis by Doppler at the time of ACA testing (p < 0.05). A logis
tic regression model was used to estimate the association between clinical
factors and access thrombosis. In this multivariate analysis, the presence
of access stenosis and a history of access thrombosis were both significant
ly associated with the development of access thrombosis. Adjusted for these
variables, neither IgG-nor IgM-ACA was significantly associated with acces
s thrombosis. The presence of an ACA was not associated with episodes of ac
cess thrombosis in either the prospective or retrospective analyses. Conclu
sion: Further investigation is required to determine if the association bet
ween aspirin use and IgM-ACA, or of IgM-ACA and access stenosis, has implic
ations for underlying pathogenetic mechanisms of access stenosis.