Recently, the concept of equal thermodynamic distance (ETD) has been propos
ed to minimize entropy production in a distillation process using a diabati
c column. ETD gives the optimal temperature profile to first-order in N-1,
where N is the number of trays. ETD, however, does not generally give the t
rue minimum for distillation columns with few trays. We therefore apply a f
ully numerical, multidimensional optimization routine to determine minimum
entropy production. Since this method does not depend on an underlying theo
ry, we expect a true minimum to be revealed. We then compare the performanc
e of ETD and numerical optimization by varying the number of trays and the
purity requirements. Our results show a surprisingly good agreement between
the ETD results and those obtained numerically. (C) 2001 Elsevier Science
Ltd. All rights reserved.