Long-term follow-up failed to detect in vitro transmission of full-length porcine endogenous retroviruses from specific pathogen-free pig islets to human cells
B. Clemenceau et al., Long-term follow-up failed to detect in vitro transmission of full-length porcine endogenous retroviruses from specific pathogen-free pig islets to human cells, DIABETOLOG, 44(11), 2001, pp. 2044-2055
Aims/hypothesis. Islets from specific pathogen-free (SPF) pigs could preven
t the transmission of conventional zoonosis. but not endogenous retroviruse
s (PERV), from pigs to diabetic patients. We previously reported that the p
ancreas showed the lowest expression of PERV mRNA among pig tissues intende
d for grafting. This study aimed to determine whether PERV from pig islets
infect human cells during co-incubation.
Methods. Human cells (including highly PERV-sensitive 293 cells) were incub
ated with SPF pig islet cells under conditions designed to increase contact
(a high islet to human cell ratio, extended period of coculture. and repea
ted contacts). PK15 and G2 retrovirus-producing pig cells were used in plac
e of islet cells as "positive infection controls". Infection of human cells
was monitored on cellular extracts and supernatants by PCR or long PCR, an
d RT-PCR or long RT-PCR. to detect PERV DNA and mRNA. respectively. Reverse
- transcriptase activity was monitored by PERT.
Results. Despite the presence of all PERV sequences in pig islet cells, inc
luding full-length inserts. no DNA or RNA for gag, pol, and the 3 env sub-t
ypes were detected in any human cell line or blood mono- nuclear cells incu
bated with pig islet cells, during an 18-week follow-up period. No PERV seq
uences or RT activity were detected in supernatants. PERV signals were nega
tive even when the pig islet to human cell ratio was increased to 100:1, th
e time of co-culture was extended to 5 days and two sequential co-incubatio
ns were done. By contrast, all PERV DNA and mRNA were detected in all human
cells co-incubated with PK15 or G2 cells. Depending on human cell types, p
roductive or non-productive infections were obtained: full-length PERV RNA
and RT activity in supernatants were detected or not; and PERV sequences to
previously unexposed human cells by PERV-infected human bells were transmi
tted or not. Some human cells were not productively infected by PK15 cells
but became productively infected after co-incubation with PERV-infected 293
cells.
Conclusion/interpretation. SPF pig islet cells, even with PERV inserts and
transcripts. have very little probability of transmitting PERV to human cel
ls during co-incubation. The sensitivity of human cells to stable and produ
ctive infection by PERV depends on the cell type. Human adaptation of PERV
was observed.