The Japanese House of Councillors is elected by a two-vote electoral system
that is a unique combination of non-unique components. As such, it provide
s a useful case to examine theories about the impact of electoral systems o
n the number of parties that will compete nationally and within each consti
tuency, and on the level of proportionality. The election is considered wit
hin a comparative context provided by two-vote elections in Germany, New Ze
aland, Scotland and Wales. It emerges that the level of vote-splitting in G
ermany, though extensively studied, is relatively low in comparative terms,
The extent and impact of malapportionment are also examined. (C) 2001 Else
vier Science Ltd. All rights reserved.