This study compared the psychological effects of Progressive Muscle Relaxat
ion (PMR) and breathing exercises. Forty-two students were divided randomly
into two groups and taught PMR or breathing exercises. Both groups practic
ed for five weeks and were given the Smith Relaxation States Inventory befo
re and after each session. As hypothesized, PMR practitioners displayed gre
ater increments in relaxation states (R-States) Physical Relaxation and Dis
engagement, while breathing practitioners displayed higher levels of R-Stat
e Strength and Awareness. Slight differences emerged at Weeks 1 and 2: majo
r differences emerged at Weeks 4 and 5. A delayed and potentially reinforci
ng aftereffect emerged for PMR only after five weeks of training-increased
levels of Mental Quiet and Joy. Clinical and theoretical implications are d
iscussed. (C) 2001 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.