Ew. Gerharz et al., QUALITY-OF-LIFE AFTER CYSTECTOMY AND URINARY-DIVERSION - RESULTS OF ARETROSPECTIVE INTERDISCIPLINARY STUDY, The Journal of urology, 158(3), 1997, pp. 778-785
Purpose: Now that creation of continent urinary reservoirs has become
a standardized and clinically well established surgical technique with
known morbidity and mortality rates, we reassessed the psychological
and social aspects of this treatment compared with wet urostomy. Mater
ials and Methods: We developed a questionnaire (102 items) addressing
general aspects of quality of life, disease related social support, co
ping strategies and stoma related issues. It was mailed to 600 patient
s with ileal conduits and 130 with continent reservoirs. Final analysi
s was restricted to 192 patients operated upon within the last 5 years
(mean followup 2,7 years). Results: The resulting groups were matched
and paralleled regarding most treatment related and sociodemographic
data. Final analysis did not reveal differences between the groups in
disease related social support, coping strategies or quality of life w
hen expressed as a total score. me found statistically significant sup
eriority of continent reservoirs regarding all stoma related items, pa
tient global self-assessment of their quality of life (single item, p
< 0.005), physical strength, mental capacity, leisure time activities
and social competence (p < 0.05). Conclusions: Continent diversion is
clearly advantageous with respect to all items directly related to the
stoma. The significant superiority of continent diversion in patient
global self-assessment of their quality of life reflects the highly su
bjective dimension of the concept. Superiority in self-ratings of phys
ical strength, mental capacity, leisure time activities and social com
petence could be interpreted as indicators of enhanced vitality in tho
se patients, thus, supporting our understanding that women and men who
actively participate in life have a special benefit from continent re
servoirs.