The desperate need for replications

Authors
Citation
Je. Hunter, The desperate need for replications, J CONSUM R, 28(1), 2001, pp. 149-158
Citations number
2
Categorie Soggetti
Economics
Journal title
JOURNAL OF CONSUMER RESEARCH
ISSN journal
00935301 → ACNP
Volume
28
Issue
1
Year of publication
2001
Pages
149 - 158
Database
ISI
SICI code
0093-5301(200106)28:1<149:TDNFR>2.0.ZU;2-6
Abstract
An overemphasis on creativity for evaluating research has lead to a serious devaluation of replication studies. However, we need a total sample size o f N = 153,669 to estimate a causal effect to two digits, which is quite rar e for a single study. The only way to get accurate estimation is to average across replications. If the average sample size were as high as N = 200, w e would need over 700 replication studies. Scientific replications are more problematic than pure statistical replications, and so we need even more r eplications to achieve reasonable accuracy.