A systematic intercomparison of three realistic eddy-permitting models of t
he North Atlantic circulation has been performed. The models use different
concepts for the discretization of the vertical coordinate, namely geopoten
tial levels; isopycnal layers, terrain-following (sigma) coordinates, respe
ctively. Although these models were integrated under nearly identical condi
tions, the resulting large-scale model circulations show substantial differ
ences. The results demonstrate that the large-scale thermohaline circulatio
n is very sensitive to the model representation of certain localised proces
ses, in particular to the amount and water mass properties of the overflow
across the Greenland-Scotland region, to the amount of mixing within a few
hundred kilometers south of the sills, and to several other processes at sm
all or sub-grid scales. The different behaviour of the three models can to
a large extent be explained as a consequence of the different model represe
ntation of these processes. (C) 2001 Elsevier Science Ltd. All rights reser
ved.