A comparative study of yield to intermediate products obtained from the dis
tributed-feed membrane reactor (MR) and the conventional cooled-tube plug-f
low reactor (PFR) is presented. The nonisothermal, nonadiabatic one-dimensi
onal pseudohomogeneous reactor model was used. The analysis is presented in
terms of the usual dimensionless groups (Damkohler number (Da), heat of re
action parameter, Stanton number (St), etc.) and delineates regions of para
meter space where the membrane reactor gives improved yield with no higher
maximum temperature. Optimal conditions for the PFR usually lie on or close
to the boundaries between either pseudo-adiabatic operation (PAO) or hot-s
pot operation (HSO), and runaway operation.
Results show that when compared under optimal operating conditions and at t
he same catalyst volume, reactant feed rate, temperature and pressure, the
membrane reactor performance is better than that of the PFR only over restr
icted regions of parameter space. In general, distributed feed is preferred
at higher Da, and under conditions of high heat release or lower cooling r
ates. The distributed-feed reactor performance can be enhanced by a mixed-f
eed strategy, or by slightly increased inlet temperature. (C) 2001 Elsevier
Science B.V. All rights reserved.