Ja. Zahn et al., Correlation of human olfactory responses to airborne concentrations of malodorous volatile organic compounds emitted from swine effluent, J ENVIR Q, 30(2), 2001, pp. 624-634
Direct multicomponent analysis of malodorous volatile organic compounds (VO
Cs) present in ambient air samples from 29 swine (Susscrofa) production fac
ilities was used to develop a 19-component artificial swine odor solution t
hat simulated olfactory properties of swine effluent. Analyses employing ei
ther a human panel consisting of 14 subjects or gas chromatography were per
formed on the air stream from an emission chamber to assess human olfactory
responses or odorant concentration, respectively. Analysis of the olfactor
y responses using Fisher's LSD statistics showed that the subjects were sen
sitive to changes in air concentration of the VOC standard across dilutions
differing by approximately 16%. The effect of chemical synergisms and anta
gonisms on human olfactory response magnitudes was assessed by altering the
individual concentration of nine compounds in artificial swine odor over a
twofold concentration range while maintaining the other 18 components at a
constant concentration. A synergistic olfactory response was observed when
the air concentration of acetic acid was increased relative to the concent
ration of other VOC odorants in the standard. An antagonistic olfactory res
ponse was observed when the air concentration of 4-ethyl phenol was increas
ed relative to the other VOC odorants in the standard. The collective odora
nt responses for nine major VOCs associated with swine odor were used to de
velop an olfactory prediction model to estimate human odor response magnitu
des to swine manure odorants through measured air concentrations of indicat
or VOCs. The results of this study show that direct multicomponent analysis
of VOCs emitted from swine effluent can be applied toward estimating perce
ived odor intensity.