Two siblings with interleukin-12 receptor beta1 (IL-12 beta1) deficiency bu
t different clinical phenotypes were studied. Both are homozygous for an IL
12RB1 missense mutation that prevents receptor expression and abolishes cel
lular responses to IL-12. Transfection of the patients' T cells with wild-t
ype IL12RB1 restored IL-12R beta1 expression and function. One patient had
the expected phenotype of disseminated bacille Calmette-Guerin (BCG) infect
ion in early childhood, whereas the other did not develop BCG infection, de
spite 3 inoculations with live BCG. Abdominal tuberculosis was diagnosed in
this second patient at age 18 years. To date, neither of them has had clin
ical disease caused by environmental mycobacteria. These observations show
unexpected interfamilial and intrafamilial heterogeneity of the clinical ph
enotype associated with IL-12R beta1 deficiency. The patients may be resist
ant to BCG but remain vulnerable to Mycobacterium tuberculosis. A diagnosis
of IL-12R beta1 deficiency should therefore be considered in selected pati
ents with severe tuberculosis, despite their resistance to BCG and a lack o
f atypical mycobacteriosis.