Hl. Smith et al., IMPLEMENTATION OF A DEMOGRAPHIC AND CONTRACEPTIVE SURVEILLANCE SYSTEMIN 4 COUNTIES IN NORTH CHINA, Population research and policy review, 16(4), 1997, pp. 289-314
This paper details efforts to implement a demographic and contraceptiv
e surveillance system in four counties in North China. These counties
are taking part in a large-scale field experiment involving the introd
uction of new contraceptives, greater choice in the use of contracepti
ves, and better training of family planning personnel. To evaluate the
impact of these changes, a system of detailed, individual-level recor
ds are being kept in the 24 townships taking part in the project. We d
iscuss the interaction between data collection and policy implementati
on - its general forms, its manifestations in modern China, and its re
levance for the current project. We describe the system that we are im
plementing - what the old system looked like, and how we have tried to
improve it, We evaluate the system's functioning over three years, ba
sed on field observations and preliminary data from one of the project
's four counties. We conclude that there has been progress in the time
ly accumulation of standardized data; but there remains an antinomy wh
ereby, past a point, an emphasis on data quality has the effect of sen
sitizing those responsible for recording data to the problematic natur
e of such data, thereby weakening accuracy. Many of the issues encount
ered in implementing the new system are relevant to the larger issues
of(a) correct interpretation of data from China, and (b) creating a re
asonable climate for change in the family planning system.