Previously, fiber and crystal structural models were proposed for bile acid
salt micellar aggregates and verified in aqueous solutions. Electromotive
force (emf) measurements on sodium salts versus ionic strength, pH, and bil
e salt concentration provided micellar aggregate compositions that supporte
d tile models. Ionic strength was varied by adding tetramethylammonium chlo
ride (TMACl), although tetramethylammonium (TMA(+)) and Na+ ions could inte
rfere in the aggregate formation and structure. In this case emf results ca
nnot be used for sodium salts. Tetramethylammonium (TMAGDC) and sodium glyc
odeoxycholate (NaGDC), which forms helical aggregates constituted by trimer
s, are studied to clarify this point. TMAGDC crystal structure is solved, a
nd circular dichroism (CD), quasi-elastic light-scattering (QELS), electrol
ytic conductance, and dielectric measurements on TMAGDC and NaGDC aqueous s
olutions are compared for determining similarities and dissimilarities in t
heir behavior. TMA(+) and Na+ coordinations in TMAGDC and NaGDC crystals sh
ow that Na+ potential energy is lower than that of TMA(+), thus suggesting
a stronger Na+ binding to glycodeoxycholate anion (GDC(-)) aggregates. Bili
rubin-Ma (Bn) chiral recognition is sensitive to aggregate structures. BR C
D spectra suggest similar structures for TMAGDC and NaGDC anion aggregates.
QELS measurements indicate that GDC(-) aggregates have a greater affinity
for Na+ ions than for TMA(+) ions and that TMA(+) ions form TMAGDC aggregat
es that are smaller than those formed by NaGDC and could interrupt NaGDC ag
gregate growth. From conductance data TMA(+) seems to be bound to anion agg
regates less than Na+, enhances its interactions when micellar size increas
es, could be included together with Cl-, coming from TMACl, into micellar a
ggregates, and could be bound through hydrophobic forces with the apolar la
teral surface of anion aggregates. High TMAGDC values of the average electr
ic dipole moment per monomer mu can be justified by cation and anion hydrat
ion. Probably, aggregate composition, population, and structure change slig
htly or do not change at all within tile range 15-45 degreesC, where mu is
nearly constant. The high single monomer mu (more than 70 D) suggests that
TMA(double dagger) is anchored to GDC(-) in dilute solution, thus forming a
n ion pair. TMAGDC and NaGDC mu trends are both interpreted assuming a two-
structure model and an equilibrium between dimeric and trimeric species. In
conclusion, TMAGDC and NaGDC bigger aggregates have similar structures, ev
en though the TMAGDC micellar size is smaller than that of NaGDC.