Jl. Campbell et al., Age, gender, socioeconomic, and ethnic differences in patients' assessments of primary health care, QUAL HEAL C, 10(2), 2001, pp. 90-95
Background-Patients' evaluations are an important means of measuring aspect
s of primary care quality such as communication and interpersonal care. Thi
s study aims to examine variations in assessments of primary care according
to age, gender, socioeconomic, and ethnicity variables.
Methods-A cross sectional survey of consecutive patients attending 55 inner
London practices was performed over a 2 week period using the General Prac
tice Assessment Survey (GPAS) instrument which assesses 13 important dimens
ions of primary care provision. Variations in scale scores were investigate
d for differences relating to age, gender, socioeconomic, and ethnic status
as reported by respondents.
Results-A total of 7692 questionnaires were returned (71% response rate). V
alid information on age, gender, socioeconomic status, and ethnicity was av
ailable for 4819 out of 5496 adult respondents. Approximately half the resp
ondents reported their ethnic group as "white" and most of the remaining re
spondents reported belonging to "black" or South Asian groups. Significant
differences existed between groups of patients defined by age or ethnicity
for most of the scale scores examined. Black, South Asian, and Chinese resp
ondents reported lower scores (representing less favourable assessments) th
an white respondents; older respondents reported more favourable evaluation
s of care than younger respondents; and less affluent groups reported lower
scores than more affluent groups for two of the 13 dimensions. There was n
o significant difference between gender groups with respect to assessment o
f primary care. Age and ethnicity were independent predictors of respondent
s' assessments of primary care.
Conclusions-Differences exist between identifiable subgroups of the populat
ion in their assessments of primary health care measured using the GPAS ins
trument. This work adds to the literature on variation in healthcare experi
ence and the potential for patient assessment of primary care, Further work
is required to investigate these differences in more detail and to relate
them to differences in the nature and process of primary care provision. Pr
imary care providers need to ensure that services provided are appropriate
for all patient groups within their communities.