Surface area is a physical property of solids that has been used as an indi
cator of reactivity and as an input parameter in chemical surface complexat
ion models of ion adsorption. This study was conducted to identify the fact
ors that affect the surface area of synthetic AL oxides and to evaluate whe
ther surface area is a stable physical property of amorphous Al oxides. Fou
r Al oxides were synthesized using four different methodologies. The surfac
e area and porosity, especially mesoporosity, were characterized using gas
adsorption, mercury intrusion porosimetry, scanning and transmission electr
on microscopy, and nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. Reactivit
y toward adsorption of berate, arsenite, arsenate, and molybdate as a funct
ion of solution pH, and ion activity products after aqueous reaction were a
lso investigated. Surface areas were found to be affected by various factor
s, including aging, drying, heating, reaction in aqueous solution, and conc
entration of the starting reagents during synthesis. Aluminum oxide mineral
s of widely differing initial surface areas measured in the dry state had s
urface areas of comparable magnitude upon reaction in aqueous solution; the
initially high surface areas decreased and the initially low surface areas
increased to a surface area of 32.4 +/- 2.8 m(2) g(-1). Initial surface ar
ea is not a good indicator of chemical reactivity for synthetic amorphous A
l oxides. Accurate surface characterization is needed at the time of reacti
on if thermodynamically unstable materials are used in adsorption studies.