This paper uses a new, large-scale, dynamic life-cycle simulation model to
compare the welfare and macroeconomic effects of transitions to five fundam
ental alternatives to the U.S, federal income tax, including a proportional
consumption tax and a flat tax. The model incorporates intragenerational h
eterogeneity, and a detailed specification of alternative tax systems. Simu
lation results project significant long-run increases in output for same re
forms. For other reforms, namely those that seek to insulate the poor and i
nitial older generations from adverse welfare changes, long-run output gain
s are modest.