Ct. Pedersen et Dm. Sylvia, LIMITATIONS TO USING BENOMYL IN EVALUATING MYCORRHIZAL FUNCTIONING, Biology and fertility of soils, 25(2), 1997, pp. 163-168
Arbuscular mycorrhizal (AM) grasses compete for nutrients with ectomyc
orrhizal (EM) pine in the southeastern United States. Our objective wa
s to determine if benomyl could be used to selectively inhibit the fun
ction of AM and thereby reduce grass competition in the field, The eff
ects of Benlate (active ingredient: benomyl) in the greenhouse and fie
ld were evaluated. No effect was observed on pine inoculated with Piso
lithus tinctorius in the greenhouse. Colonized root length of benomyl-
treated Zen mays L. plants inoculated with Glomus sp. in the greenhous
e remained static over time and the response was not dose dependent at
concentrations of 0, 20, 60 and 150 kg benomyl ha(-1) equivalent. In
contrast, colonization of nontreated plants increased over time. In th
e field, a minimal reduction of grass colonization was observed follow
ing four applications of benomyl ranging from 5 to 20 kg hd(-1) We con
clude that benomyl can successfully inhibit development of AM fungi un
der controlled conditions in the greenhouse with no inhibitory effects
on the EM fungus P. tinctorius; however, in the field several factors
may interfere with the effect of benomyl on AM fungi. These factors i
nclude: (a) the presence of ground cover which obstructs penetration o
f the fungicide to the soil, (b) timing of application in relation to
mycorrhizal development, and (c) the application method of benomyl, a
soil drench being preferable to a foliar spray.