Eighteen soils from south-western Australia were used to measure the effect
iveness of 2 reactive phosphate rocks (RPR) [North Carolina and Sechura (Ba
yovar) RPRs] relative to superphosphate (relative effectiveness, or RE) usi
ng (i) yield of dried shoots of 30-day-old wheat plants (RE yield), (ii) P
content of the dried shoots (REPcontent), and (iii) bicarbonate soil test P
(REbicP) as measures of effectiveness. The RE values were positively relat
ed to PR dissolution in soil, titratable acidity, and to P and Ca retention
by soil, and were negatively related to soil pH.
No single soil property adequately predicted REyield, REPcontent, or REbicP
. Stepwise multiple regression indicated that: (1) PR dissolution, soil pH,
and organic carbon together accounted for about half the variation in REyi
eld; (2) organic C, soil pH, and titratable acidity together accounted for
about 67% of the variation in REPcontent; (3) PR dissolution, P retention c
apacity, and titratable acidity together accounted for about 71% of the var
iation in REbicP. We conclude that the agronomic effectiveness of phosphate
rock fertilisers is a consequence of complex interactions of phosphate roc
k with soil that cannot be adequately predicted by measurements of a single
soil property.