Despite theories suggesting that the cognitive impact of comparative advert
isements differs from that of noncomparative ads, little progress has been
made toward empirically understanding the types of mental representations e
ngendered by these forms of advertising. The current research provides evid
ence pertinent to this issue across three experiments. As anticipated, comp
arative ads are more likely to cause mental impressions about the advertise
d brand relative to competitors than are noncomparative ads. The results al
so indicate that differentiative comparative ads generate disassociative ra
ther than the associative mental impressions previously thought to characte
rize the processing of such ads. In addition, the findings demonstrate that
both relative and nonrelative impressions may be formed following exposure
to comparative ads. Implications are drawn for interpreting the findings o
f prior investigations, as well as for undertaking future research on compa
rative advertising.