Recently, the accuracy of vapor nucleation rate measurements has increased
substantially. However, when experimental conditions become close to the va
lues to the critical parameters of investigated systems, significant discre
pancies were found between the experimental results and theoretical predict
ions. Some studies have found agreement between results and theory only wit
hin a narrow range of nucleation conditions. Therefore, it is appropriate t
o investigate the nucleation of additional systems to obtain new informatio
n to guide nucleation theory development. Alcohols are the most studied cla
ss of chemical compounds, but currently there are no experimental data on n
-octanol vapor nucleation. The present study is devoted to the investigatio
ns of the homogeneous nucleation of the n-octanol in sulfur hexafluoride. C
omparison of the critical pressures for binary mixture with the Laplace pre
ssure calculated in the droplet approximation using the bulk liquid surface
tension shows that the carrier gas has a more active role in the nucleatio
n than assumed by classical theory. A very high Laplace pressure in the cri
tical embryo is calculated in the droplet approximation. When compared with
the highest possible critical pressure for the binary system under investi
gation, the problems associated with calculating the critical embryo excess
energy using the bulk liquid surface tension are revealed. Disagreement of
the experimental results with predictions of classical nucleation theory,
Dillmann-Meier theory, or any other theory reveals the same basic problems.
These results suggest that it is appropriate to consider the general probl
em of vapor-liquid nucleation in a carrier gas including the estimation of
the size and temperature dependence of the critical embryo excess energy as
a binary nucleation problem instead of that of a single component. Theorie
s for single-component vapor nucleation should be compared with the truly s
ingle-component vapor nucleation experimental results. (C) 2001 American In
stitute of Physics.