Two intersterility groups occur within Collybia subnuda. The two inter
sterility groups retain a low level of intercompatibility in vitro. Th
ey are similar morphologically and have nearly identical intergenic tr
anscribed spacer rDNA sequences. Intersterility group 1 is usually fou
nd on oak leaf litter, while intersterility group 2 is usually found a
ssociated with oak wood. Collection records and the results of interco
llection pairing among single-spore isolates indicate that the two int
ersterility groups are sympatric throughout the Appalachian Mountains
and into New York. Both intersterility groups produce binucleate basid
iospores in low frequency, and thus have the potential for secondary h
omothallism. A mechanism for sympatric evolution of heterothallic Basi
diomycetes is proposed, but neither a sympatric nor allopatric origin
for the C. subnuda ISGs is advocated.