Transgenic Bt potato and conventional insecticides for Colorado potato beetle management: comparative efficacy and non-target impacts

Field studies were conducted in 1992 and 1993 in Hermiston, Oregon, to eval uate the efficacy of transgenic Bt potato (Newleaf(R), which expresses the insecticidal protein Cry3Aa) and conventional insecticide spray programs ag ainst the important potato pest, Leptinotarsa decemlineata (Say), Colorado potato beetle (CPB), and their relative impact on non-target arthropods in potato ecosystems. Results from the two years of field trials demonstrated that Newleaf potato plants were highly effective in suppressing populations of CPB, and provided better CPB control than weekly sprays of a microbial Bt-based formulation containing Cry3Aa, bi-weekly applications of permethri n, or early- and mid-season applications of systemic insecticides (phorate and disulfoton). When compared with conventional potato plants not treated with any insecticides, the effective control of CPB by Newleaf potato plant s or weekly sprays of a Bt-based formulation did not significantly impact t he abundance of beneficial predators or secondary potato pests. In contrast to Newleaf potato plants or microbial Bt formulations, however, bi-weekly applications of permethrin significantly reduced the abundance of several m ajor generalist predators such as spiders (Araneae), big-eyed bugs (Geocoru s sp.), damsel bugs (Nabid sp.), and minute pirate bugs (Orius sp.), and re sulted in significant increases in the abundance of green peach aphid (GPA) , Myzus persicae (Sulzer) - vector of viral diseases, on the treated potato plots. While systemic insecticides appeared to have reduced the abundance of some plant sap-feeding insects such as GPA, lygus bugs, and leafhoppers, early and mid-season applications of these insecticides had no significant impact on populations of the major beneficial predators. Thus, transgenic Bt potato, Bt-based microbial formulations and systemic insecticides appear ed to be compatible with the development of integrated pest management (IPM ) against other potato pests such as GPA because these CPB control measures have little impact on major natural enemies. In contrast, the broad-spectr um pyrethroid insecticide (permethrin) is less compatible with IPM programs against GPA and the potato leafroll viral disease.