;The protonation site, aromaticity, charge distribution, and NMR properties
of 3-aminothiophene, 3,4-diaminothiophene, aniline, and 1,2-benzenediamine
have been investigated by means of quantum chemical calculations both for
the isolated and solvated species tin water and DMSO). For the isolated spe
cies (G3-(MP2) level), the C-protonated form of aminothiophenes is more sta
ble than the N-protonated form (by 5-9 kcal/mol), whereas the stability ord
er of the protonated forms of anilines is reversed, with a closer energy ba
lance (2-5 kcal/mol). In water or DMSO the stability of the C- and N-proton
ated forms of aminothiophenes is essentially the same las obtained by a com
bination of G3(MP2) and DFT-IPCM solution data), whereas for anilines a str
ong preference for N-protonation is borne out. However, a comparison of exp
erimental and calculated C-13 NMR chemical shifts shows N-protonation to be
the major process in solution. While the aromaticity of the two ring types
(as probed by nucleus-independent chemical shifts) is very similar, the la
rger nucleophilicity of the C-2 atom of aminothiophenes as compared to anil
ines is shown to arise from a strong polarization of the C-2-C-3 bond.