Navy Shipboard Power Systems have different characteristics when compared w
ith utility power systems. To conduct system studies on shipboard power sys
tems. an effective simulation tool is required to model the Shipboard Elect
ric Power Systems. This paper presents the results of the analysis of three
popular simulation tools, ATP, PSpice and Saber for transient simulation o
f Shipboard Electric Power Systems (SPSs). The results suggest that ATP is
a good tool for generating detailed component models and calculating model
parameters directly from standard specifications and ratings of the equipme
nt. PSpice and Saber have an excellent graphical interface for building com
plex SPSs and flexibility in establishing monitoring points and processing
output data. (C) 2001 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.