In finite elasticity, the number of exact solutions which apply to all mate
rials of a general class, such as compressible or incompressible hyperelast
ic materials, is known to be limited. The question arises, however, as to w
hether or not we might determine the largest sub-class of such materials fo
r which a particular deformation is a possible solution of the governing eq
uations. In this note, for a certain family of non-symmetrical plane strain
deformations for hyperelastic materials, we determine every strain-energy
function which gives rise to a non-trivial deformation of this type. A prev
iously obtained solution for the Mooney material and several recently obtai
ned solutions applying to special strain-energy functions are all shown to
be deduced from a general formulation. In addition, a new solution is deriv
ed here, also applying to a particular strain-energy function. The purpose
of this note is to demonstrate that for physically meaningful response func
tions no further exact solutions of this type exist.