Breeds of larger mature size tend to grow more rapidly and be older when at
taining a given level of fatness. Hereford, Limousin, and Piedmontese are o
f approximately equal mature size and yet may vary in body composition at a
given degree of maturity. However, direct comparisons among these three br
eeds were not found. Therefore, the objective of this research was to compa
re Hereford, Limousin, and Piedmontese progenies for economically important
traits. Crossbred cows were bred to Hereford (n = 23), Limousin (n = 24),
or Piedmontese (n = 24) sires. Male calves were either left intact or castr
ated at approximately 2 mo of age. Calves remained with their dams until we
aning at an average age of 179 d. Male calves were then individually fed a
growing ration until they reached 386 kg and then fed a finishing ration ei
ther 90 or 132 d. They were then slaughtered at a commercial abattoir and c
arcass data were collected, Female calves were group-fed and used to examin
e nutritional effects on age at puberty. Data were analyzed using REML and
linear contrasts among the breed-of-sire effects evaluated. Hereford-sired
calves had shorter gestation periods and weighed less at birth than either
Limousin- or Piedmontese-sired calves. Calving difficulty of Hereford- and
Limousin-sired calves was less than that of Piedmontese-sired calves. Limou
sin-sired calves tended to grow more rapidly than Hereford-sired calves. By
the finishing phase, Limousin- and Hereford-sired calves had greater avera
ge daily gains than Piedmontese-sired calves. Differences in dry matter int
ake among breeds of sire were relatively small. Differences in carcass weig
ht, longissimus muscle area, fat depth, and percentage kidney, pelvic, and
heart fat resulted in a clear stratification of USDA yield grade between br
eeds of sire. Differences in percentage primal cuts were similar to those f
or USDA yield grade. Hereford-sired calves had more marbling than progeny o
f Limousin or Piedmontese sires. However, the force necessary to shear core
s from steaks of Piedmontese-sired calves was less than for progeny of Limo
usin or Hereford sires. Hereford- and Piedmontese-sired heifers were younge
r at puberty than Limousin-sired heifers. Within breeds of similar mature s
ize and growth rate, ample variation exists in age at puberty and body comp
osition at an approximately equal degree of maturity.