Rh. Marrs et Aj. Frost, A MICROCOSM APPROACH TO THE DETECTION OF THE EFFECTS OF HERBICIDE SPRAY DRIFT IN PLANT-COMMUNITIES, Journal of environmental management, 50(4), 1997, pp. 369-388
It is often difficult to measure and predict the impacts of toxic chem
icals, such as herbicides, on natural communities. This is especially
true under conditions of spray drift when the amount received by the o
rganisms downwind from the sprayer may be at sub-lethal doses. Laborat
ory experiments are either artificial, or have not been generally carr
ied out over long enough time periods, to be realistic. Field experime
nts are often difficult because of the high variability inherent in na
tural populations. Here an intermediate microcosm approach was used, w
here standardized artificial communities (eight dicotyledons with and
without a grass) were tested. The artifical communities included speci
es typical of British woodland margins, hedgerows and field margins; c
ommunities with a high conservation interest, yet potentially under th
reat from spray drift. The microcosms were placed downwind of a spraye
r and exposed to one of the following herbicides: glyphosate, mecoprop
and MCPA. This approach ensures that the communities were standardize
d at the start and have been exposed to realistic doses of herbicide.
The experiments reported here were carried out for at least three year
s with exposures to herbicides repeated each year. The effects of diff
erential herbicide exposure downwind of the sprayer were measured on s
pecies yield, flowering performance, seed production, seed viability a
nd invasion by new species. Responses were extremely variable, but all
species showed some effects in some years. Some patterns emerged. For
example, one group of species appeared to be more successful near to
the sprayer. This was particularly true of the grass when exposed to M
CPA and mecoprop. The performance of most species was reduced under th
e sprayer, and there was a general recovery with increasing distance d
ownwind. A few species showed increased performance in the intermediat
e downwind zone (2-4 m) and this may be due to a hormonal effect on gr
owth processes, or an effect of reduced interference from other commun
ity members. Generally there were few effects on seed production or se
ed viability. An important result was that most effects were confined
within an 8 m zone, as there were few significant differences between
plants exposed at 8 m and those untreated. Although damaging effects w
ere found in the immediate downwind zone from the sprayer, the restric
tion of effects to 8 m suggests that a buffer zone of this size would
be adequate to protect sensitive habitats from most deleterious impact
s on community processes. (C) 1997 Academic Press Limited.