Re. Taylor et al., RELATION BETWEEN PSYCHIATRIC-DISORDER AND ABNORMAL ILLNESS BEHAVIOR IN PATIENTS UNDERGOING OPERATIONS FOR CERVICAL DISKECTOMY, Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery and Psychiatry, 63(2), 1997, pp. 169-174
Objective-To test the hypothesis that depression in patients being con
sidered for cervical disc surgery is associated with severe organic pa
thology. Secondly, to test whether depression and abnormal illness att
itudes recorded preoperatively would predict poorer recovery. Methods-
Seventy four patients with pain and disability from cervical arthrosis
were examined during investigations before potential cervical surgery
. The prevalence of psychiatric disorder was assessed using the SCAN,
and attitude to illness using the illness attitude scale. Results-Ther
e was a rate of depressive disorder in the sample of 37%, The depresse
d patients did not have more severe organic pathology, more neurologic
al symptoms or signs, or more disablement. They reported more pain and
displayed more abnormal illness behaviour. Fifty patients went on to
cervical surgery. Outcome four to eight months postoperatively was not
related to the presence of psychiatric disorder or illness attitude r
ecorded preoperatively. Conclusion-Depressive disorder is not secondar
y to severe pathology; the outcome of surgery is predominantly determi
ned by physical factors.