Vo. Speights et al., NEUROENDOCRINE STAINS AND PROLIFERATIVE INDEXES OF PROSTATIC ADENOCARCINOMAS IN TRANSURETHRAL RESECTION SAMPLES, British Journal of Urology, 80(2), 1997, pp. 281-286
Objective To determine whether the quantification of certain neuroendo
crine and proliferative markers would help in the prognostic evaluatio
n of prostatic adenocarcinomas obtained during transurethral resection
of the prostate (TURF).Materials and methods Samples from two groups
of patients with prostate cancer were examined. One group comprised 23
patients, of whom 12 were stage TV and 11 stage III, all with Gleason
scores of greater than or equal to 7; this group was designated as hi
gh-grade, high-stage (HGHS). The second group comprised 10 consecutive
patients with stage Tla adenocarcinoma of the prostate with Gleason s
cores of less than or equal to 6, designated as low-grade, low-stage (
LGLS) tumours. Tumour tissue from each TURF was stained with MIB-1 (an
indicator of cell proliferation), neuron-specific enolase (NSE), chro
mogranin A (ChA) and synaptophysin (Syn), and 1000 cells counted to de
termine the percentages of positive cells in both benign and malignant
tissue. The percentage of MIB-1-positive cells was designated as the
proliferative index (PI). Patients were clinically followed to evaluat
e tumour progression, documented by rising prostate-specific antigen (
PSA) levels, X-ray evidence of recurrent or metastatic carcinoma, or t
issue biopsy showing malignancy. Results The mean number of neuroendoc
rine cells (NEC) for each marker and the mean PI were greater in the H
GHS tumours than in the LGLS tumours or surrounding benign tissue of e
ither group (P < 0.01). The LGLS tumours were remarkable for a having
mean PI of about twice that of the benign tissue (2.9 and 1.3, respect
ively, P < 0.01); the NEC in these cases were more frequent in the ben
ign than in the malignant tissue, There was no significant difference
between the mean PIs and the mean percentages of NEC in the 14 HGHS tu
mours that progressed and the nine HGHS tumours that did not (P values
0.37-0.96). Conclusions Although the PI assessed by MIB-1 and the num
ber of NEC-positive cells were much higher in HGHS than LGLS tumours,
this finding did not appear to have independent prognostic significanc
e, The significance of the higher PI in LGLS tumours than in correspon
ding benign tissue is uncertain; LGLS tumours bad fewer NEC than the s
urrounding benign tissue. The quantification of any of these four mark
ers (MIB-1, NSE, ChA, Syn) was not prognostically helpful in these gro
ups of cancers present in TURF specimens.