In the mid 1980s, concern arose over the rise of sexually explicit ser
vices on the French videotex system. In examining the legal implicatio
ns of these messageries roses, this article reviews how French courts
applied criminal law to penalize providers of allegedly pornographic m
essage services. Although the Tribunal correctionnel de Paris relied o
n statutory law to resolve the Neron case, it refused to extend existi
ng print and audiovisual media laws to cover videotex, based on a judi
cial precedent against the applicability of press legislation to broad
casting. In July 1991, the Court of Appeals of Amiens condemned three
messagerie rose managers as accomplices of users who had produced porn
ographic announcements because they had intentionally permitted these
actions to occur by providing users the means to publicize messages en
couraging debauchery.