P. Finn et al., CHILDREN RECOVERED FROM STUTTERING WITHOUT FORMAL TREATMENT - PERCEPTUAL ASSESSMENT OF SPEECH NORMALCY, Journal of speech language and hearing research, 40(4), 1997, pp. 867-876
Current evidence suggests that young children who recover from stutter
ing are essentially stutter-free. However, there is no evidence to ind
icate if their speech is perceptually indistinguishable from normally
fluent peers or whether they retain perceptually unusual speech. One i
mportant example of recovery From stuttering is children who have reco
vered without receiving formal treatment. An investigation was conduct
ed to determine if the speech of these children is perceptually differ
ent from the speech of children who have never stuttered. Speakers con
sisted of 10 preschool and early school-age children documented as rec
overed from stuttering without benefit of Formal treatment. In a serie
s of studies they were compared with 10 children who had never stutter
ed. Three groups of judges-sophisticated, unsophisticated, and experie
nced-were separately asked, using videotaped speech samples of the chi
ldren, to decide which samples were from children who used to stuffer.
Results revealed that the children who recovered from stuttering were
perceptually indistinguishable from the normal controls. The same res
ult was obtained regardless of whether the samples were presented in p
aired-stimulus or single-stimulus mode. Two of the groups of judges we
re also instructed to rate the speech naturalness of the speech sample
s. The speakers were not distinguished on this measure either. Methodo
logical issues and the implications of the Findings are discussed.