Gml. Villagra et P. Felker, INFLUENCE OF UNDERSTORY REMOVAL, THINNING AND P FERTILIZATION ON N-2 FIXATION IN A MATURE MESQUITE (PROSOPIS-GLANDULOSA VAR GLANDULOSA) STAND, Journal of arid environments, 36(4), 1997, pp. 591-610
The natural abundance N-15/N-14 method was used to estimate the influe
nce of silvicultural and P fertilization treatments on N accretion, N-
2 fixation and N partitioning among tissues in a mature mesquite Proso
pis glandulosa var. glandulosa stand in Texas. The silvicultural treat
ments consisted of understory removal, herbicide treatment of brushy r
esprouts, thinning trees to single stems and 100 kg ha(-1) P fertiliza
tion. The trees had a mean basal diameter of 17.8 cm with 8 to 35 cm r
ange. The stand was slow growing with the increase in dry matter rangi
ng from 0.465 Mg ha(-1) year(-1) to 0.701 Mg ha(-1) year(-1) for the 8
years after the treatments were applied. N accretion after 8 years ra
nged from 3.1 kg ha(-1) year(-1) to 4.4 kg ha(-1) year(-1). Due to the
range in delta(15)N of the leaves, twigs, branches and trunk, we used
the weighted (by biomass) average delta(15)N per tree in calculations
of the percent N derived from N-2 fixation (%Ndfa). There was conside
rable variability in delta(15)N Of the reference plants, i.e. from 3.3
to 5.9. In contrast there was low variability in the background delta
(15)N of nearby soils (7.0 +/- 1.0). As the total above-ground biomass
delta(15)N Of a grass grown outside the influence of mesquite (7.8 +/
- 0.58) had the same delta(15)N as the soil (7.5 +/- 1.0), we used the
grass outside the influence of mesquite and the weighted tree mean de
lta(15)N to calculate % of N derived from N-2 fixation. The decrease i
n intraspecific competition by thinning multistemed trees to single st
emmed trees was the only treatment that significantly (p = 0.0001) inc
reased growth. Interspecific competition, i.e. understory removal, did
not increase growth. There were no significant differences in total N
production or N fixation among treatment means. The most striking res
ult was the highly positive correlation between tree delta(15)N and to
tal N per tree and biomass per tree (R-2 = 0.90, F = 164.4, df. = 18,
Mean square error (MSE) = 0.155, p 0.0001). This implies that the youn
ger trees colonizing infertile soils relied more heavily on N-2 fixati
on than larger trees which accumulated 1200 kg ha(-1) more N under the
ir canopies. The percentage N derived from N-2 fixation ranged from 63
to 73% in the various treatments. Despite the high percentage of N de
rived from N-2 fixation, the N-2 fixation of the stand was very low, i
.e. 1.98 to 2.80 kg N ha(-1) year(-1), due to the low growth of the st
and. We believe that comparisons of the whole tree weighted delta(15)N
to background soil delta(15)N provides a more reasonable approach to
estimate % N-2 fixation than comparisons of leaves of fixers and refer
ence plants.