The evolution of group living remains an outstanding question in evolu
tionary ecology. Among the most striking forms of group living are the
enormous assemblages of breeders that occur in many colonial marine b
irds and mammals, with some colonies containing more than a million in
dividuals breeding in close contact. Coloniality is an evolutionary pu
zzle because individuals pay fitness costs to breed in high densities.
Despite numerous potential benefits proposed to overcome these costs,
we still lack a general framework to explain coloniality. Several new
hypotheses involving breeding habitat and mate selection create promi
sing approaches for studying this enigma.