Trypsin and chymotrypsin differ strikingly in substrate specificities
despite great similarity in their primary and tertiary structures. Thi
s work analyzes the role of two surface loops, loop 40 and loop 60, as
structural determinants of the specificity of the S1'-subsite in chym
otrypsin and trypsin. Chymotrypsin prefers P1' Arg/Lys residues, while
trypsin prefers hydrophobic P1' residues. We replaced loop 40 and loo
p 60 in trypsin with their chymotrypsin counterparts. These mutations
do not affect the S1 specificity and catalytic activity of trypsin. Th
e S1' specificity was analyzed by monitoring acyl-transfer reactions t
o 16 amino acid amides. The exchange of loop 40 does not affect the S1
' specificity. In contrast, the replacement of loop 60 causes a loss o
f specificity for P1'-Met/Ile/Leu. Combining both mutations reconstitu
tes a chymotrypsin-like S1' specificity. The specificity for Arg-NH2 i
ncreases 3-fold while the preferences for Met-NH2 and Ile-NH2 decrease
4- and S-fold, respectively. Therefore, P1'-Arg/Met discrimination ch
anges by factor 12 and P1'-Arg/Ile discrimination changes by factor 24
, Thus, loop 40 and loop Ga act synergistically to determine S1' speci
ficity in trypsin and chymotrypsin.