O. Parra et al., SHOULD PATIENTS WITH SLEEP APNOEA HYPOPNOEA SYNDROME BE DIAGNOSED ANDMANAGED ON THE BASIS OF HORNE SLEEP STUDIES/, The European respiratory journal, 10(8), 1997, pp. 1720-1724
The purpose of this study was to analyse the validity and the economic
efficiency of a portable monitor of respiratory parameters (PMRP), us
ed in a home setting for the diagnosis of sleep apnoea/hypopnoea syndr
ome (SAHS). Eighty nine patients with suspected SAHS were studied in t
wo settings: in the sleep laboratory using full-polysomnography (full-
PSG); and st the patient's home using a PMRP. In the home setting, 50
patients were assisted by a technician and 39 set up the equipment the
mselves. SAHS (apnoea/hypopnoea index (AHI) >10 events.h(-1) by means
of full-PSG) was diagnosed in 75 of the 89 patients. An acceptable agr
eement was obtained between the AHI measured by full-PSG and PMRP, acc
ording to the Bland and Altman method of concordance (mean bias 2.56;
95% confidence interval 3.25), Sensitivity and specificity of PMRP wer
e adequate for diagnostic purposes; however, their values rely on the
prior PMRP-AHI cut-off point selected with reference to full-PSG-AHI >
10. The clinical therapeutic decision taken after PMRP agreed with tha
t taken with full-PSG in 79 patients (89%). Although 10% of the studie
s with an individual set-up needed repetition, both of the domiciliary
modalities (with and without a technician's intervention) were, econo
mically, about three times more efficient than full-PSG. In conclusion
, we believe that patients with a suspected sleep apnoea/hypopnoea syn
drome should initially be studied in a home setting with a portable mo
nitor of respiratory parameters, since it is a reliable method with an
acceptable cost-effective profile.