N. Choudhury et al., COMPARISON OF PLASMA-LIPIDS AND VITAMIN-E IN YOUNG AND MIDDLE-AGED SUBJECTS ON POTATO CRISPS FRIED IN PALMOLEIN AND HIGHLY OLEIC SUNFLOWER OIL, Annals of nutrition & metabolism, 41(3), 1997, pp. 137-148
We previously found no difference in healthy young adults' plasma chol
esterols between palmolein and olive oil as the major dietary lipid, a
lthough the former is high in palmitic acid (16:0) but the latter in o
leic acid (18:1 cis). In the experiment reported here we compared the
effects of palmolein against another monounsaturated oil, highly oleic
sunflower oil (HOSO), on plasma cholesterol in both young and middle-
aged healthy adults. The test oils were provided as frying oil of pota
to crisps (150 g/day in men; 100 g/day in women) against low-fat backg
round diets in free-living motivated volunteers. The design was a rand
omised double-blind 4-week/3-week crossover trial. Compliance was moni
tored with continuous dietary diaries and by measuring (fasting) plasm
a lipid fatty-acid pattern. Plasma Lipids and vitamin-E compounds were
measured at the start and twice at the end of each test period. In co
mbined young plus older subjects (n = 42) mean plasma total and low-de
nsity-lipoprotein cholesterol (LDL-c) values were both 7% (significant
ly) lower on HOSO than on palmolein, but because high-density-lipoprot
ein cholesterol (HDL-c) was also 5% lower, the LDL-c/HDG-c ratio was o
nly 3% lower on HOSO than on palmolein. The difference between the pre
sent results with HOSO and previous results with olive oil both compar
ed against palmolein suggest that olive oil is associated with higher
plasma cholesterols than other monounsaturated oils. In both the young
and older subgroup, LDL-c was lower on HOSO but because HDL-c moved d
own too in the young subgroup, the LDL-c/HDL-c ratio was lower on HOSO
only in the older subjects. Palmolein has an unusual pattern of E vit
amins, with a high content of tocotrienols, notably the gamma-isomer.
Unlike alpha-tocopherol however, there was no sign of these tocotrieno
ls in subjects' plasmas.